The appeal is dismissed and outline planning permission si refused for the erection of 6 open market dwellings and 7 2 bed dwellings to rent, traffic calming and estate road on land in Middleton, Ludlow,Shropshire. The application reference 14/02442/OUT dated 20 May 2014 was refused by notice dated 14 December 2015. The appeal is made by Mr Mark Wiggan against Shropshire Council.